Houston v Shiels (No 2) — NSW Supreme Court dismisses second plaintiff’s claim as having no viable cause of action

Case
Houston v Shiels (No 2)
Court
Supreme Court of New South Wales
Judge
Gregory Sirtes (of New South Wales Margaret Beazley AC KC, 2026)
Date Decided
28 September 2026
Citation
[2026] NSWSC 1178
Topics
Civil procedure, summary dismissal, pleadings, costs

Background

Joanne Houston and Trevor Karlsson commenced proceedings in May 2024 against Barry John Shiels, Kelly Shiels and Benjamin Kirby. Ms Houston sought $4,839,182 described as reparations for alleged damage to her south-coast property across a series of fires, a break-in and other incidents. Mr Karlsson sought $1, but the amended statement of claim did not explain the basis for that claim or identify any loss he had suffered.

In May 2026, solicitors then acting for Ms Houston filed a notice discontinuing the whole proceeding, purportedly on behalf of both plaintiffs and with the defendants’ consent. Mr Karlsson, who was imprisoned following convictions for offences against Kelly Shiels, said he had neither signed nor authorised the notice. Sirtes J accepted that contention for present purposes without deciding it. Ms Houston did not pursue withdrawal of the discontinuance.

The Court’s Holding

The Court dismissed Mr Karlsson’s claim under r 13.4(1) of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW), which permits dismissal where no reasonable cause of action is disclosed. The Court held that, even taking his case at its highest, the amended statement of claim concerned only Ms Houston’s property and alleged losses.

There was no pleaded head of damage for Mr Karlsson and no articulated basis on which he could recover $1 from any defendant. Although summary dismissal must be exercised carefully and only in clear cases, the Court found this claim was doomed to fail. Mr Karlsson was ordered to pay the defendants’ costs.

Key Takeaways

  • A claimant must plead facts establishing a recognisable cause of action and a basis for the relief sought.
  • A court may summarily dismiss a claim under r 13.4 where the pleading discloses no reasonable cause of action.
  • The Court did not need to decide whether Mr Karlsson had authorised the discontinuance because his claim independently could not succeed.

Why It Matters

The decision illustrates the limited but important summary-dismissal power in NSW civil litigation. Even where a litigant disputes a procedural step said to have been taken in their name, the proceeding may still be dismissed if the claim itself contains no pleaded case against the defendants.

✉️ Get tomorrow’s cases before your first coffee
Daily Case Law is our free morning digest — the most substantive new decisions, filtered to your jurisdictions and topics, each linking back here for the full analysis.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top