Background
Michael and Dianna Fernandez executed a $160,000 note secured by their home and later modified the loan during a Chapter 13 bankruptcy. In 2015, the loan servicer reversed four payments without explaining why, although Dianna Fernandez testified that she made the payments and never received the funds back. The Fernandezes continued making monthly payments through April 2017. The servicer returned their May 2017 payment because it did not include the four reversed payments and refused later attempts to make a single monthly payment.
The Bank sued for foreclosure in 2021, alleging a continuing default beginning January 1, 2017. After a bench trial, the circuit court found Dianna Fernandez credible, found no competent explanation for the four reversals, and entered judgment against the Bank for failure to prove a default. The Bank appealed.
The Court’s Holding
The Second District reversed. Putting aside the improperly unexplained reversals, the undisputed evidence established that the Fernandezes made no payments from June 2017 onward. Because each missed monthly payment constituted a separate default and the complaint alleged a continuing default, those later missed payments supplied legally sufficient evidence of default. The servicer’s rejection of the May 2017 payment did not, by itself, excuse the borrowers’ continuing obligation to make timely payments.
The court also held that neither tender nor unclean hands justified denying foreclosure. The Fernandezes did not possess or offer the amount needed to bring the loan current when the action began, and the evidence did not show fraud, trickery, or similarly unscrupulous conduct by the Bank or its agents. On remand, however, the circuit court must exclude the principal represented by the four reversed payments, interest before June 2017, and fees claimed before July 2017, and may reduce any attorney-fee award by amounts attributable to litigating the reversals. Judge Atkinson concurred in the result, while Judge Silberman dissented and would have affirmed based on the trial court’s supported factual and equitable findings.
Key Takeaways
- A payment-accounting dispute does not, without more, relieve a borrower of the obligation to continue making timely mortgage payments.
- Each missed monthly payment is a separate default, so later nonpayments can support foreclosure despite a dispute over an earlier alleged default.
- Tender requires an actual offer and ability to pay, while unclean hands requires misconduct more serious than imprudent, unfair, or unfriendly loan servicing.
Why It Matters
The decision limits a trial court’s ability to deny foreclosure based solely on a servicer’s mishandling or rejection of earlier payments when undisputed later defaults remain. At the same time, it prevents the lender from recovering amounts tied to unexplained payment reversals and permits adjustment of attorney’s fees attributable to that dispute.