The Federal Circuit affirmed dismissal of Amgen’s doctrine of equivalents infringement claim, holding that arguments made during patent prosecution create estoppel bars even when those arguments were not strictly necessary to secure allowance of the claims.
The Federal Circuit affirmed invalidity of Enzo’s nucleotide labeling patents for lack of enablement, holding that claims covering tens of thousands of possible labeled polynucleotide embodiments were not enabled when the specification disclosed only a few working examples.
The Federal Circuit reversed a district court’s dismissal of patent claims as ineligible under § 101, applying Berkheimer to hold that well-pleaded factual allegations about how the claimed invention was an unconventional advance must be accepted as true at the 12(b)(6) stage — limiting early
The Federal Circuit held that state sovereign immunity does not apply in inter partes review proceedings, following the logic of its earlier St. Regis Mohawk Tribe ruling and closing the gap between tribal and state immunity claims at the PTAB.
The Federal Circuit affirmed that patent claims directed to displaying profit-and-loss data on a trading screen were ineligible under § 101 because merely presenting new financial information on a generic display does not solve a technical problem.
The Federal Circuit held that patents covering network-controlled electric vehicle charging stations are directed to the abstract idea of network communication for device interaction, invalidating all four asserted patents under § 101.
The Federal Circuit reversed a district court’s ruling that Endo’s oxymorphone dosing patent was ineligible, holding that claims directed to a specific method of treating specific patients with specific dosages are not merely abstract natural laws.
The Federal Circuit upheld SRI’s network intrusion detection patents against a § 101 challenge, holding that claims requiring computers to perform surveillance and analysis that the human mind is incapable of doing are not directed to abstract ideas.
The Federal Circuit reversed a district court’s ruling that patents on using beta-alanine as a dietary supplement were invalid under § 101, holding that method of treatment claims covering use of a natural compound in non-naturally-occurring quantities to alter physiology are patent eligible.
The Federal Circuit invalidated a diagnostic patent for detecting autoantibodies linked to myasthenia gravis, then denied en banc rehearing in a rare decision accompanied by eight separate opinions, exposing the court’s deep division over § 101 and diagnostic patents.