The Federal Circuit ruled that the widely used ’25 percent rule of thumb’ for calculating starting-point patent royalties is inadmissible as a matter of law, vacating a $388 million damages award against Microsoft and requiring that every patent royalty calculation be tied to the specifi
The Federal Circuit upheld Prometheus’s patents on methods for optimizing thiopurine drug dosing based on metabolite blood levels, holding the claims directed to patent-eligible subject matter because they applied natural correlations through a physical transformation — a ruling the Supreme Co
The Federal Circuit upheld patents on digital image halftoning technology as patent-eligible subject matter, holding that mathematical algorithms applied to specific, practical technological problems are not so abstract as to be excluded from § 101, and cautioning against an overly rigid application
The Federal Circuit reversed a summary judgment of obviousness in a deepwater drilling rig patent dispute, holding that the district court failed to give adequate weight to powerful objective evidence of non-obviousness — including commercial success, long-felt need, and failure of others — and rema
The Federal Circuit applied claim differentiation and rejected a narrowing construction of defibrillator patent claims, holding that independent claims cannot be read to require limitations found only in dependent claims — and affirmed the district court’s infringement finding on the broader i
The Federal Circuit held AstraZeneca’s patents on a once-daily budesonide inhaler formulation (Pulmicort Respules) valid and infringed in a Hatch-Waxman challenge, affirming the district court’s analysis of the complex obviousness record and reinforcing the significance of FDA-required l
The Federal Circuit sitting en banc held that 35 U.S.C. § 112 contains a written description requirement that is distinct from the enablement requirement, and invalidated a broad genus patent covering all substances that inhibit NF-κB activity because the patent described the goal but not the means.
The Federal Circuit affirmed a $200 million jury verdict and permanent injunction against Microsoft for infringing i4i’s patent on a method for editing custom XML in word processing documents, rejecting Microsoft’s invalidity defense premised on a prior-sold product and upholding the cle
The Federal Circuit vacated a patent damages award and held that a reasonable royalty calculation must rely on licenses that are technologically and economically comparable to the patent at issue — rejecting a royalty rate derived from re-bundling agreements that had no connection to the claimed inv
The Federal Circuit affirmed summary judgment of invalidity of a patent on a method for bulk email delivery, holding the claims obvious under post-KSR standards where the claimed process involved only routine, predictable steps well within the common sense of a person with ordinary skill in email ma