Federal Case Summaries
Clear all
Coverage since November 3, 1994

Federal

Uncategorized

Mentor Graphics v. EVE-USA (2017) — Federal Circuit Holds Panduit Lost Profits Analysis Satisfies Apportionment Without Separate Apportionment Step

The Federal Circuit held that when a patentee satisfies all four Panduit factors for lost profits — including proving demand driven by the patented feature and no acceptable non-infringing substitutes — no further separate apportionment of those profits is required, because the Panduit analysis inhe

Uncategorized

Intellectual Ventures v. Capital One Financial — Federal Circuit Strikes Down XML and Data-Collection Patents as Abstract Ideas

The Federal Circuit affirmed invalidation of Intellectual Ventures’ XML-formatting and financial data-collection patents under Section 101, holding that organizing, collecting, recognizing, and storing data — even when dressed in domain-specific vocabulary — is a patent-ineligible abstract ide

Uncategorized

Praxair Distribution v. Mallinckrodt Hospital — Federal Circuit Holds Nitric Oxide Dosing Method Patent Ineligible

The Federal Circuit held Mallinckrodt’s patents on methods of supplying inhaled nitric oxide therapy while monitoring patients for adverse effects were patent-ineligible under § 101 — finding the claims directed to the natural phenomenon that nitric oxide can worsen pulmonary edema in certain

Uncategorized

WesternGeco v. ION Geophysical — Federal Circuit Bars Foreign Lost Profit Damages Under Section 271(f), Later Reversed by Supreme Court

The Federal Circuit reversed a $93 million foreign lost-profits award for ION’s domestic infringement under Section 271(f), holding that the presumption against extraterritoriality barred recovery for overseas contracts WesternGeco would have won absent the infringement — a ruling the Supreme

Uncategorized

McRO v. Bandai Namco — Federal Circuit Upholds Animation Lip-Sync Patents as Patent-Eligible Improvements to Computer Animation

The Federal Circuit held that McRO’s patents on rule-based automated lip synchronization in 3D character animation were patent-eligible — the claims specified a particular improvement in computer animation technology using specific rules, not merely the abstract idea of using rules to automate

Uncategorized

Stryker Corp. v. Zimmer Inc. (2016 Remand) — Federal Circuit Applies New Halo Standard, Remands Enhanced Damages Determination to District Court

On remand from the Supreme Court’s Halo Electronics decision, the Federal Circuit affirmed the jury’s willfulness finding under the new subjective standard but vacated the enhanced damages award, instructing the district court to exercise its discretion anew — illustrating how post-Halo

Uncategorized

Electric Power Group v. Alstom — Federal Circuit Holds Power Grid Monitoring Patents Invalid as Data-Collection Abstract Ideas

The Federal Circuit held that patents on real-time monitoring and analysis of electric power grid data were patent-ineligible under Section 101, establishing that collecting, analyzing, and displaying information — even in a complex industrial context — is an abstract idea without an inventive conce

Scroll to Top