Uncategorized

Kaufman v. Microsoft Corp. — Federal Circuit Upholds $7 Million Patent Damages Verdict, Addresses Claim Construction Preservation and Prejudgment Interest

The Federal Circuit affirmed a $7 million patent infringement damages verdict against Microsoft, holding that claim construction challenges must be preserved in a party’s opening brief to be raised on appeal, and reversed the denial of prejudgment interest as an abuse of discretion.

Uncategorized

Google LLC v. IPA Technologies Inc. — Federal Circuit Vacates IPR Decision for Failure to Resolve Conflicting Testimony on Prior Art Inventorship

The Federal Circuit vacated a PTAB final written decision for failing to resolve conflicting expert testimony about whether a third party qualified as a joint inventor of a prior art reference, holding that the Board cannot deem all witnesses credible when their accounts are mutually contradictory.

Uncategorized

Auris Health, Inc. v. Intuitive Surgical Operations — Federal Circuit Holds General Industry Skepticism Cannot Negate Motivation to Combine

The Federal Circuit reversed the PTAB’s finding of non-obviousness, holding that generalized industry skepticism about robotic surgery cannot alone overcome a motivation to combine prior art references — the skepticism must target the specific problem addressed by the claimed invention.

Scroll to Top