Background
The father sought an order under the 1980 Hague Convention requiring the return to Ukraine of C, a six-year-old boy whom the mother removed in May 2025. The mother accepted that C had been habitually resident in Ukraine, that the father was exercising custody rights, and that the removal was wrongful under Article 3.
The mother relied solely on the Article 13(b) exception. She alleged domestic abuse against herself and C, cited the escalating missile and drone attacks around Poltava and the family’s village, and argued that returning C would worsen her depression and impair her ability to care for him. The father denied the abuse, disputed the level of wartime danger, and offered undertakings and financial assistance intended to facilitate a safe return.
The Court’s Holding
Mr Justice MacDonald dismissed the return application. Taken at their highest, the domestic-abuse allegations established a grave risk of physical or psychological harm, but Ukrainian law provided sufficiently effective protective mechanisms, including restraining and emergency protection orders, to address that risk. The mother’s mental health, considered separately, did not establish an intolerable situation for C; the court considered it likely that she would accompany him despite saying that she would not.
The war-related risk did satisfy Article 13(b). The court found that the expanding use of missiles and drones away from the front lines had reduced the usefulness of fine geographic distinctions within Ukraine. Recent strikes near Poltava and the family’s village created at least a low risk of death or life-changing injury, whose exceptional severity made the risk grave.
The father’s proposed safeguards did not adequately manage that danger. His late proposal to relocate to the Zhytomyr region lacked evidence that the region was materially safer, while a possible later evacuation or return to England would not protect C from the risk created by the initial return. Because the wartime risk could not be sufficiently mitigated, the court declined to exercise its residual discretion to order C’s return.
Key Takeaways
- War in Ukraine does not automatically defeat a Hague Convention return application, but the court must assess the particular child’s prospective circumstances and the conflict’s current character and reach.
- A low probability of death or life-changing injury may constitute a “grave risk” under Article 13(b) because the magnitude of the possible harm is extreme.
- Protective measures must concretely and effectively address the identified risk; unsupported relocation or future-evacuation proposals are insufficient.
Why It Matters
The judgment recognizes that the increased reach and frequency of aerial warfare may make earlier, highly location-specific assessments of safety in Ukraine less reliable. Distance from the ground front line is no longer necessarily a meaningful answer to the risk posed by missiles, drones, and falling debris.
It also illustrates the required separation between identifying a grave risk and deciding whether that risk can be managed. Although Ukrainian legal protections were sufficient to address the assumed domestic-abuse risk, no proposed measure adequately protected the child from the independently established wartime danger.