Litigation Cases
Coverage since January 1, 2026

Litigation

Uncategorized

Santa Clara Valley Water District v. Eisenberg — Preliminary Injunction Compelling Director to Return Confidential Investigation Reports Affirmed

Sixth District affirms a mandatory preliminary injunction compelling a sitting Santa Clara Valley Water District board member to return two confidential investigation reports she removed from district facilities, holding the claim-and-delivery law did not bar parallel injunctive relief.

Uncategorized

Stanz v. Brown — S.D. Cal. Magistrate Recommends Civil Contempt and Coercive Per-Diem Fine for Defendants’ Failure to Pay $11,400 Fee Award

After defendants ignored a court order to pay an $11,400 attorney-fee award, the magistrate judge certified facts to the district judge supporting civil contempt and recommended a coercive per-diem fine, but recommended denying the plaintiff’s request for additional fees on the contempt motion

Uncategorized

Stanz v. Brown — S.D. Cal. Magistrate Recommends Civil Contempt for Defendants’ Refusal to Comply With Discovery Order, but Declines Adverse-Inference and Default-Judgment Sanctions

After defendants in a private-jet brokerage dispute substantially failed to comply with a court order requiring document production and on-site electronic-storage inspection, the magistrate judge recommended civil contempt and coercive per-diem fines, but declined to recommend the harsher remedies o

Uncategorized

McElroy v. Pernod Ricard — S.D. Cal. Lets Failure-to-Warn Claim Survive in Sparkling-Wine Bottle Injury Case but Dismisses Design-Defect and Negligence Claims

In a personal-injury suit by a consumer who lacerated her hand when a Mumm Napa Valley sparkling wine bottle exploded after she used a corkscrew to remove a stuck cork, the court granted summary judgment on the design-defect and negligent-storage claims but allowed the failure-to-warn claims to proc

Uncategorized

Matthews v. Ryan — Section 998 Settlement Offer Conditioned on Insurer Consent Was Valid; Trial Court Must Reconsider Prejudgment Interest

Second District holds a personal-injury plaintiff’s pretrial settlement offer conditioned on the defendant’s insurer’s consent was a valid Code of Civil Procedure section 998 offer, because insurer consent is a necessary condition of any insured-defendant settlement whether stated

Uncategorized

Conservatorship of B.K. — Trial Court Adequately Honored LPS Conservatee’s Jury-Trial Rights Where She Personally Withdrew the Demand After Counsel Consultation

Second District affirms a one-year LPS conservatorship renewal, holding the trial court adequately honored the conservatee’s jury-trial rights where she demanded a jury trial, was given time to consult counsel, and then personally withdrew her demand and confirmed her choice on the record.

Uncategorized

Department of Water Resources v. Metropolitan Water District — DWR’s Bond Authority for Delta Conveyance Project Fails Validation Because the ‘Delta Program’ Is Too Vaguely Defined

Third District affirms denial of validation for Department of Water Resources bond resolutions tied to the long-running Delta Conveyance Project, holding the ‘Delta Program’ is so loosely defined that it cannot qualify as a permitted modification of the Feather River Project unit of the

Scroll to Top